Commons
*In a nutshell: 'a commons' is a shared thing between a bunch of people that they actively maintain together.
The idea is that they are "beyond market and state".
Commons can be found in all kinds of walks of life - the environment (grazing lands, fisheries, community forests), culture, digital realm, knowledge commons.
There's a lot to unpack. My favourite book on commons and commoning is Free, Fair and Alive.
The logic of the commons is the logic of a common humanity that has realized that all humans should be equal participants and beneficiaries in society (see Dyer-Witheford 1999, 2007, 2009; Fuchs 2011b; Hardt and Negri 2009; Žižek 2010).
1. What is a commons?
Also what's the difference between 'the Commons' and 'a commons'?
The Commons is a means of provisioning and governance that generally doesn't need the permission of legislatures or courts to move forward.
– David Bollier, Stir to Action Issue 30
The commons are cared for by the those that directly inhabit and gain from its wealth.
Despite vivid differences among commons focused on natural resources, digital systems, and social mutuality, they all share structural and social similarities.
So instead of conceiving of commons as closed systems of common property managed by a “club,” it is more productive to see them as social organisms who, thanks to their semi-permeable membranes, can interact with larger forces of life — communities, ecosystems, other commons.
The commons is not simply about “sharing,” as it happens in countless areas of life. It is about sharing and bringing into being durable social systems for producing shareable things and activities.
Commons are living social systems through which people address their shared problems in self-organized ways.
The commons is a robust class of self-organized social practices for meeting needs in fair, inclusive ways.
Each commons depends on social processes, the sharing of knowledge, and physical resources. Each shares challenges in bringing together the social, the political (governance), and the economic (provisioning) into an integrated whole.
The elemental human impulse that we are born with — to help others, to improve existing practices — ripens into a stable social form with countless variations: a commons.
1.1. How big is a commons?
In a commons, the resource can be small and serve a tiny group (the family refrigerator), it can be community-level (sidewalks, playgrounds, libraries, and so on), or it can extend to international and global levels (deep seas, the atmosphere, the Internet, and scientific knowledge).
The commons can be well bounded (a community park or library); transboundary (the Danube River, migrating wildlife, the Internet); or without clear boundaries (knowledge, the ozone layer).
2. Why?
the commons is not just about small-scale projects for improving everyday life. It is a germinal vision for reimagining our future together and reinventing social organization, economics, infrastructure, politics, and state power itself.
The commons is a social form that enables people to enjoy freedom without repressing others, enact fairness without bureaucratic control, foster togetherness without compulsion, and assert sovereignty without nationalism.
A commons … gives community life a clear focus. It depends on democracy in its truest form. It destroys inequality. It provides an incentive to protect the living world. It creates, in sum, a politics of belonging.”
The virtue of the commons as a mode of thought and action isn’t simply that it provides for the scaled management of pooled resources, but that it spurs us to envision a way of life founded in interdependence, mutuality and shared responsibility for the outcomes experienced by others. Any situation organized in this way offers us a way to get outside of ourselves, a scaffolding for the development of intersubjectivity.
Where market logics generally seek to collectivize risk and privatize gain, adherents to the principles of the commons believe that the greatest degree of sustainable benefit is derived from resources when they are held jointly, and managed democratically for the good of all.
3. Politics of it
The world of commoning represents a profound challenge to capitalism because it is based on a very different ontology.
4. Difficulties for commons
Potential problems in the use, governance, and sustainability of a commons can be caused by some characteristic human behaviors that lead to social dilemmas such as competition for use, free riding, and over- harvesting. Typical threats to knowledge commons are commodification or enclosure, pollution and degradation, and nonsustainability.
5. Related
6. Elsewhere
6.1. In my garden
Notes that link to this note (AKA backlinks).
- 2021-06-19
- Ecosocialism
- Commons-based Internet
- 2023-08-14
- Social Transformation Through 'The Commons'
- What is the relationship between cooperatives and the commons?
- Venture communism
- 2021-05-16
- Coops and commoning
- Jackson Rising
- The Care Manifesto
- Sovereignty for the Commons
- Digital commons
- Institutional Analysis and Development
- Silke Helfrich & David Bollier: What Is The Commons?
- A Platform Designed for Collaboration: Federated Wiki
- Comparing market, state and commons
- Murray Bookchin
- Free, Fair and Alive
- Silke Helfrich
- Trip 35: The Internet
- Goteo
- 2022-08-08
- Distributed Cooperative Organisation
- I like the commons
- 8 principles for managing a commons
- Kate Raworth on Why Our Times Demand 'Doughnut Economics'
- Community land trusts
- Future Histories
- enclosure of the commons
- The Stack as an Integrative Model of Global Capitalism
- Nathan Schneider - Cooperatives, the Commons and Ownership
- commoning
- This Land is Our Land
- Imperialism is the Arsonist: Marxism's Contribution to Ecological Literatures and Struggles
- 2021-05-13
- David Bollier
- The Internet as a Super-Commons
- 2022-08-09
- bolo'bolo
- Elinor Ostrom's Rules for Radicals
- New Forest
- 2021-10-31
- Value flows
- A commons is a politics of belonging
- Food commons
- 2020-07-26
- 2021-05-15
- 2021-06-06
- Well-connected
- P2P Accounting for Planetary Survival